Kevin Drum recently set off a firestorm on the female side of the lefty political blogosphere for openly musing about reasons for the lack of female representation in the (flawed) NZ Bear ecosystem, the embers of which are still raging. Ezra took on the issue here, and a good discussion followed. Ezra subsequently added more female bloggers to his sidebar, including the excellent Julie Saltman. Personally, I don't read or link to nearly as many female bloggers as male bloggers, but I'm not sure I can explain why. Am I a jerk? I didn't have any opinion whatsoever on the Larry Summers controversy, although I think that firing people for things they say once is usually an extreme reaction (there may be other valid reasons for Harvard faculty to toss him out though). But I guess I just don't think about gender very much, and my reading habits have become increasingly narrow. Our beloved Nadezhda, obviously, is female, as are KatherineR and Hilzoy of one of the blogosphere's last bastions of bipartisan discussion, Obsidian Wings. I read them regularly and with gusto. Then there's also Garance France-Rutka of TAPPED (the lone woman!), and the award-winning Jeralyn Merritt at TalkLeft, who I read less often but with similar enthusiasm. I used to read Respectful of Otters but she seems to have disappeared. And then there's the incomparable Belle Waring, who also posts on Crooked Timber from time to time, which has taken up the gender-in-political-blogging thing on numerous occasions, though with little practical effect. And Elizabeth Anderson of Left2Right has become a blogosphere force in an astonishingly short period of time.
Meanwhile, I can't help but notice that, quietly, Big Media Matt has been breaking out of his usual habits and linking to more female writers and discussing gender issues in a more sensitive way than in the past, studiously immune to the slings and arrows directed his way. Sneaky.
UPDATE: I seem to have spoken too soon.
|
|
|||||
Comments
Re: Show, Don't Tell
by
Dave Schuler
on Thu 24 Feb 2005 03:43 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
You might consider checking in at media girl. I'm a constant reader, frequent booster, and occasional commenter of hers.
The core issue in Kevin's post is Top 20 rankings of left-leaning female bloggers. I wonder if one of the main factors isn't that Daily Kos sucks an enormous proportion of the traffic that might otherwise go to other left-leaning bloggers (men and women). Re: Show, Don't Tell
by
Dave Schuler
on Thu 24 Feb 2005 03:43 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
You might consider checking in at media girl. I'm a constant reader, frequent booster, and occasional commenter of hers.
The core issue in Kevin's post is Top 20 rankings of left-leaning female bloggers. I wonder if one of the main factors isn't that Daily Kos sucks an enormous proportion of the traffic that might otherwise go to other left-leaning bloggers (men and women). Re: Re: Show, Don't Tell
by
praktike
on Thu 24 Feb 2005 05:13 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
But it's so ... red! I'll check it out, though, thanks.
Re: Show, Don't Tell
by
KatherineR
on Thu 24 Feb 2005 06:59 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
This is to some extent biting the hand that fed me, because he was the first of the biggies to link to OW and has been extremely supportive and is generally a mensch. But Kevin Drum probably gets an extra amount of crap because he has about 8 blogs that include a woman poster on his entire blogroll--and I mean, counting things like TAPPED and OW and the Corner where it's a mainly-male group blog. And he doesn't have a short blog roll. He links to at least three times as many conservative weblogs as female-written ones, and many of them aren't even any good and moreover are sites that everyone already knows about. He also has a high proportion of the old boys club weblogs that aren't very good now if they ever were.
So then when he says that weblogs are an egalitarian paradise, and there can be no barriers to entry, and is completely unresponsive to points about what he could do if he thinks it's a concern--he comes off as pretty clueless. In general the big-time sites seem to feel an obligation to link to their forefathers--Mickey Kaus is one of about 9 sites Josh Marshall links to, for example-- but they don't seem to feel an obligation to promote good liberal sites that others may not have heard of. And plenty of liberal sites stilll blogroll Instapundit. Bit of a boys club. There's actually a pretty similar dynamic to law review at my school. It's a gender blind essay competition and yet it's only about 30% women, tops. And with weblogs,it's not gender blind, and people clearly tend to assume a blogger is of their gender, and maybe they tend to notice them more or less accordingly. I've mistaken plenty of guys for gals and the reverse is even more common. And I was the one who suggested hilzoy join OW, for example. That's a good point
by
praktike
on Thu 24 Feb 2005 07:24 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Do you think he also ignores trackbacks from female bloggers?
Re: That's a good point
by
KatherineR
on Thu 24 Feb 2005 10:34 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
not really. I mean, he may, but I have no basis for thinking so. It mainly looks like he hasn't updated his blogroll in over a year--he's missing a lot of really great liberal sites that are reasonably well known.
I don't think it's just Kevin
by
MC MasterChef
on Fri 25 Feb 2005 08:57 AM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
I mean, check out the winners of the Koufax Awards. Not a whole lot of unfamiliar faces there really.. people tend gravitate around the few major sites they already know.
oops, I forgot
by
praktike
on Thu 24 Feb 2005 11:02 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Laura Rozen, who for g-d's sake is my top referrer over at the other place! Shame on me.
Re: oops, I forgot
by
Haggai
on Thu 24 Feb 2005 11:56 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Tapped also gets occasional contributions from Sarah Wildman, though she doesn't seem to post as often as Garance. They also used to have the occasional post from Ayelish McGarvey.
Trackbacks
TrackBack URL: |
Recent Articles
Great minds and all thatThis Turkey Won't Fly One picture says it all Obama's exercise in rhetoric Obama Grand Tour and McCain Circus Roundup Biden has Obama's Afghan back = update - and the Pentagon too Bush's Pakistan-Afghanistan-Iran "legacy" - updated Then WTF is a "bail-out"? Blogging making reporters more relevant Ignatius and Zakaria - new WaPo joint venture Reasserting US Hegemony: Russian rollback, Chinese containment and Iranian regime change What's up A "paddling" of lame ducks? Voices of the New Arab Public Time for a post-post-9/11 world? Blake Hounshell (aka praktike), our co-founder and main man, is now web editor of Foreign Policy. blakehounshell [at] gmail Blake's personal blog
The Satin Pajama
NOMINEE Best non-Euro Blog
The first afoe European weblog awardsSponsored by A Fistful of Euros Hey, we didn't win, but we almost beat out the Head Heeb for 2nd place! Thanks for the votes Click here for a really slick page of results and links to all the nominees in 18 different categories -- some wonderful blogs to explore, so check them out! Search
Month Archive
Login
|
||||
|
|
|||||

The first afoe European weblog awards