Warning: fairly shameless praise. Professor Haqqani — who I believe may be reading this blog — may want to cover his ears.
Today was the last day of Professor Haqqani's class for this semester; we've spent the past few classes with mostly just open discussion, since a lot of the heavy content was weighted more towards the early part of the course. So today we all handed in our papers, and spent most of the remaining time going around discussing them with everybody talking about what they'd wrote... I have to say I actually envy Professor Haqqani the grading task he has ahead of him, because I was really amazed at the diversity of topics covered by people in their papers. My paper is one example of someone going deeper on some of the issues we raised in class, but there are so many others that people could — and did — cover when given a topic as broad and as deep as Islam and South Asian politics.
In some classes, that kind of breadth would make it hard to find any grounding in the subject, but my personal experience in Professor Haqqani's class has been quite different. After having gotten sucked into Steve Coll's Ghost Wars this summer, I was keen to learn more about a region I had previously known very little about, and Prof. Haqqani helped me expand that interest in the early weeks of his class. Having given us a broader base of knowledge to start from, he then stepped back and let us take it further by focusing down in our papers. Having increased my knowledge of the Uyghurs from basically nothing to.. well, something maybe midway in between bare familiarity and the kind of deep scholarship present in my sources, the only thing I found myself wishing at the end is that I could read all the other topics my classmates had chosen to focus on, so that I could share in their research and collectively deepen the whole breadth of knowledge I had acquired during the lecture parts of the course.
In any case, I think it's been one of the best courses I've taken at BU to date, and am immensely glad I went for it when the opportunity to register came over the summer. (The class I had been planning on taking, History of War, was also quite good according to an ex-roomate who's taking it, but having literally finished Ghost Wars the day before recieving an e-mail indicating the presence of the new class, I knew this was an opportunity I shouldn't pass up.) I have another class with Prof. Haqqani next semester — Islamic Political Movements and U.S. Policy — which I have equally high hopes for; expect to hear about it in the future.
|
|
|||||||
Islam in South Asia Wrapup
by
MC MasterChef
at 09:28PM (EST) on December 7, 2004 | Permanent Link
Comments
Re: Islam in South Asia Wrapup
by
praktike
on Tue 07 Dec 2004 11:02 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Hey, was it me that recommended Ghost Wars to you, or were you already interested in it? I can't remember the sequence.
If I recall correctly
by
MC MasterChef
on Wed 08 Dec 2004 12:16 AM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
You recommended Charlie Wilson's War -- or had read it and I saw you mentioning it and so decided to pick it up, I can't remember which exactly -- and then when I posted some comments after having read that on a Tacitus diary, spc67 recommended Ghost Wars as a followup, which you seconded, I believe.
Ah, yes
by
praktike
on Wed 08 Dec 2004 12:45 AM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
It's all coming back to me now ...
Re: Islam in South Asia Wrapup
by
Nitin Pai
on Wed 08 Dec 2004 02:41 AM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Not sure if you guys have read Ahmed Rashid's book on the Taliban. It is an easy, but very interesting and informative read.
Yep
by
MC MasterChef
on Wed 08 Dec 2004 09:17 AM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
I still have to sit down and tackle Jihad at some point in the future though. Thanks for the link on the Uyghur piece, by the way.
Re: Islam in South Asia Wrapup
by
praktike
on Wed 08 Dec 2004 09:11 AM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
yup
Trackbacks
TrackBack URL: |
Recent Articles
Great minds and all thatThis Turkey Won't Fly One picture says it all Obama's exercise in rhetoric Obama Grand Tour and McCain Circus Roundup Biden has Obama's Afghan back = update - and the Pentagon too Bush's Pakistan-Afghanistan-Iran "legacy" - updated Then WTF is a "bail-out"? Blogging making reporters more relevant Ignatius and Zakaria - new WaPo joint venture Reasserting US Hegemony: Russian rollback, Chinese containment and Iranian regime change What's up A "paddling" of lame ducks? Voices of the New Arab Public Time for a post-post-9/11 world? Blake Hounshell (aka praktike), our co-founder and main man, is now web editor of Foreign Policy. blakehounshell [at] gmail Blake's personal blog
The Satin Pajama
NOMINEE Best non-Euro Blog
The first afoe European weblog awardsSponsored by A Fistful of Euros Hey, we didn't win, but we almost beat out the Head Heeb for 2nd place! Thanks for the votes Click here for a really slick page of results and links to all the nominees in 18 different categories -- some wonderful blogs to explore, so check them out! Search
Month Archive
Login
|
||||||
|
|
|||||||

The first afoe European weblog awards